Cupcakes

CUPCAKE MENU

Sarah’s offers four classic cupcake flavors as well as specialty flavors available daily at the shop. We ask that  you call ahead for any cupcake orders over 2 dozen. When ordering from our daily rotating menu, please choose from the cupcakes available the day you are picking up your order.

Cupcakes can be ordered in any flavor combination of your choice. They can also be customized to match the theme and color of your special event, corporate event or wedding. We have a 1 dozen minimum requirement for customized cupcake orders.  Prices for custom designed cupcakes vary upon design.

BASIC BUTTERCREAM SWIRL

Our basic cupcake available in yellow, chocolate or white cake topped with a swirl of our traditional buttercream.

EACH: $2.00  DOZEN: $24.00

MINI CUPCAKES

A smaller version of our classic or specialty cupcakes without the filling.

DOZEN: $18.00 – $24.00

CLASSIC CUPCAKES

Available in the Cake Shop daily

SNACK CAKE

This is our version of a Hostess snack cake and Sarah’s bestseller! We start with our rich chocolate cake and fill it with our sweet decorators frosting and top it off with vanilla buttercream dipped in chocolate ganache.

EACH: $2.50  DOZEN: 30.00

RED VELVET

Our Red Velvet is our second best selling cupcake. It’s our twist on a Southern favorite. We start with our moist buttermilk cake and top it with our cream cheese frosting.

EACH: $2.50  DOZEN: $30.00

VANILLA CREAM

Our classic yellow cake topped with a vanilla buttercream flower. Almost too pretty to eat.

EACH: $2.25  DOZEN: $27.00

TRIPLE CHOCOLATE

Our double chocolate cake is topped with a dollop of chocolate frosting and a chocolate buttercream swirl. There’s no such thing as too much chocolate.

EACH: $2.50  DOZEN: $30.00

CUPCAKE OF THE MONTH

EACH: $2.75  DOZEN: $33.00

SPECIALTY CUPCAKES

Monday

STRAWBERRY TUXEDO

Strawberry cake filled with ganache and topped with white chocolate buttercream.

EACH: $2.75  DOZEN: $33.00

GOLDEN SNACK CAKE

Yellow cake filled with chocolate frosting, topped with our vanilla buttercream and dipped in white chocolate ganache.

EACH: $2.50  DOZEN: $30.00

SALTED CARAMEL

Caramel cake brushed with caramel, topped with a caramel buttercream and sprinkled with sea salt.

EACH: $2.75  DOZEN: $33.00

Tuesday

TIRAMISU

Vanilla bean cake brushed with coffee marsala syrup, topped with a mascarpone frosting and shaved chocolate.

EACH: $2.75  DOZEN: $33.00

CHOCOLATE BIRTHDAY CAKE

Chocolate cake filled with our sweet decorators frosting, topped with chocolate buttercream and a sprinkle of chocolate milk crumbs.

EACH: $2.75  DOZEN: $33.00

CARROT CAKE

Our moist carrot cake is filled with pineapple, coconut, and pecans, topped with our cream cheese frosting.

EACH: $2.50  DOZEN: $30.00

Wednesday

CITRUS MAPLE

Rich date cake brushed with maple syrup and filled with maple white chocolate mousse, topped with orange scented buttercream.

EACH: $2.75  DOZEN: $33.00

RAZZMATAZZ

A runner up in our Create-A-Cupacke Contest!

Chocolate cake baked with raspberries, filled with white chocolate ganache and topped with a hazelnut cappuccino buttercream.

EACH: $2.75  DOZEN: $33.00

SALTED CARAMEL

Caramel cake brushed with caramel, topped with a caramel buttercream and sprinkled with sea salt.

EACH: $2.75  DOZEN: $33.00

Thursday

BUTTERFINGER SHOT

Yellow cake filled with chocolate frosting, topped with a butterscotch schnapps buttercream and crushed Butterfinger.

EACH: $2.75  DOZEN: $33.00

CARROT CAKE

Our moist carrot cake is filled with pineapple, coconut, and pecans, topped with our cream cheese frosting.

EACH: $2.50  DOZEN: 30.00

BANANA CHOCOLATE CHIP

Banana cake baked with chocolate chips and topped with a chocolate buttercream.

EACH: 2.75  DOZEN: $33.00

CHERRY ALMOND STREUSEL

White cake baked with tart cherries, topped with our traditional buttercream and an almond ginger crumb.

EACH: $2.75  DOZEN: $33.00

Friday

CHOCOLATE SALTED CARAMEL

Caramel cake filled with whipped salted caramel, topped with chocolate buttercream with a drizzle of chocolate ganache.

EACH: $2.75  DOZEN: $33.00

DATE NIGHT

A runner up in our Create-A-Cupcake contest!

Our almond cake filled with chocolate ganache and topped with strawberry buttercream.

EACH: $2.75  DOZEN: $33.00

HAPPY HOUR SURPRISE

You will just have to stop by the shop and find out what our Happy Hour Surprise is!

EACH: $2.75  DOZEN: $33.00

CARROT CAKE

Our moist carrot cake is filled with pineapple, coconut, and pecans, topped with our cream cheese frosting.

EACH: $2.50  DOZEN: $30.00

Saturday

WIRED WILBUR

Chocolate espresso cake dipped in coffee caramel ganache, topped with chocolate buttercream and a piece of chocolate covered bacon.

EACH: $2.75  DOZEN: $33.00

LEMON BEAR

Lemon honey cake brushed with a lemon honey glaze, topped with a lightly scented lemon mascarpone frosting.

EACH: $2.75  DOZEN: $33.00

APPLE PIE, OH MY

Grand Prize Winner of our Create-A-Cupcake Contest!

Our white velvet cake baked with a cinnamon brown butter and filled with apple compote, topped with vanilla bean buttercream and a piece of pie crust.

EACH: $2.75  DOZEN: $33.00