Cupcakes

Cupcake Menu

Sarah’s offers five classic flavors as well as specialty flavors available daily in our shop.

When ordering from our daily rotating menu, please choose from the cupcakes available the day you are picking up your order.

Cupcakes can be ordered in any flavor combination of your choice. They can be customized to match the theme and color of your party, corporate event or wedding. We have a 1 dozen minimum requirement for customized order.

Prices vary for custom designed cupcakes.

 

BASIC BUTTERCREAM SWIRL

Our basic cupcake is available in yellow, chocolate or white cake topped with a swirl of buttercream.

EACH $2.25 DOZEN: $27.00

 

MINI CUPCAKES

A smaller version of our classic or specialty cupcakes.

$1.50-$1.75 Minimum dozen required

 

 

CLASSIC CUPCAKES

Available in shop daily (mini cupcakes on Monday’s)

 

SNACK

This is our version of a very popular snack and our best seller.

Dark chocolate cake filled with our sweet decorators frosting,

topped with vanilla buttercream and dipped in ganache.

EACH: $2.75   DOZEN: $33.00

 

RED VELVET

Moist buttermilk cake topped with sweet cream cheese frosting.

#2 at the shop!

EACH: $2.75   DOZEN: $33.00

 

VANILLA CREAM

Our classic yellow cake topped with a vanilla

buttercream flower…almost to pretty to eat.

EACH: $2.50   DOZEN: $30.00

 

TRIPLE CHOCOLATE

Our double chocolate cake topped with a dollop of chocolate frosting

and a swirl of chocolate buttercream.

EACH: $2.75   DOZEN: $33.00

 

DAILY DESIGN

Chocolate or yellow cake topped with our sweet decorators

frosting in a fun design.

EACH: $2.75   DOZEN: $33.00

 

 

DAILY SPECIALTY CUPCAKE MENU

 

MINI MONDAY

ALL SHOP CUPCAKES ARE MINI ON MONDAY’S

 

MINI TWIX

Caramel cake baked on shortbread cookie crumb, filled with caramel,

topped with chocolate frosting, dipped in ganache and

sprinkled with shortbread crumbs.

EACH: $1.75   DOZEN: $21.00

 

MINI WEDDING CAKE

Almond cake topped with our traditional buttercream.

EACH: $1.50   DOZEN: $18.00

 

 

TUESDAY

 

CHOCOLATE CARAMEL PRETZEL

Chocolate cake baked on a buttery pretzel crust, filled with

caramel pastry cream, topped with vanilla bean buttercream,

drizzled with ganache and crushed pretzels.

EACH: $2.75   DOZEN: $33.00

 

DATE NIGHT

Almond cake filled with chocolate ganache

and topped with strawberry buttercream.

EACH: $2.75   DOZEN: $33.00

 

 

WEDNESDAY

 

ROLO

Chocolate cake filled with caramel, topped with caramel buttercream,

dipped in ganache and topped with a mini Rolo.

EACH: $2.75   DOZEN: $33.00

 

LEMON BEAR

Lemon honey cake, brushed with a lemon honey glaze and

topped with lemon scented mascarpone frosting.

EACH: $2.75   DOZEN: $33.00

 

 

THURSDAY

 

STRAWBERRY MILKSHAKE

Vanilla bean cake filled with white chocolate mousse, topped with

strawberry buttercream, a dollop of vanilla buttercream and a cherry.

EACH: $2.75   DOZEN: $33.00

 

CARROT CAKE

Our moist carrot cake filled with pineapple, coconut and pecans,

topped with our sweet cream cheese frosting.

EACH: $2.75   DOZEN: $33.00

 

CHOCOLATE SALTED CARAMEL

Caramel cake filled with whipped salted caramel, topped with

chocolate buttercream and a drizzle of ganache.

EACH: $2.75   DOZEN: $33.00

 

 

FRIDAY

 

BOOZY BITES

Join us for Happy Hour all day long with our new Boozy Bites!

 

MINI cupcakes created after our favorite ADULT drinks.

Available in 6 flavors and you MUST be 21 to purchase.

EACH: $1.75 OR   3 FOR $5.00

 

 

SATURDAY

 

TIRAMISU

Vanilla bean cake brushed with a coffee Marsala syrup, topped with a mascarpone frosting and chocolate curls.

EACH: $2.75   DOZEN: $33.00

 

COOKIE DOUGH

Chocolate chip cake brushed with brown sugar syrup, topped with a cookie dough buttercream and mini chocolate chips.

EACH: $2.75   DOZEN: $33.00

 

CHOCOLATE BIRTHDAY CAKE

Chocolate cake filled with sweet frosting, topped with chocolate buttercream and a sprinkle of chocolate milk crumb.

EACH: $2.75   DOZEN: $33.00

 

CARROT CAKE

Our moist carrot cake filled with pineapple, coconut and pecans,

topped with our sweet cream cheese frosting.

EACH: $2.75   DOZEN: $33.00