Cupcakes

Cupcake Menu

  • Sarah’s offers five classic flavors as well as specialty flavors available daily in our shop.
  • Prices vary for custom designed cupcakes.
  • When ordering from our daily rotating menu, please choose from the cupcakes available the day you are picking up your order.
  • Cupcakes can be ordered in any flavor combination of your choice. We have a 1 dozen minimum requirement for customized order.

BASIC BUTTERCREAM SWIRL – Each: $2.25 | Dozen: $27.00

Our basic cupcake is available in yellow, chocolate or white cake topped with a swirl of buttercream.

MINI CUPCAKES – $1.50-$1.75 (1 dozen minimum)

A smaller version of our classic or specialty cupcakes.
Available on Mondays.

Classic Cupcakes

Available in shop daily (mini cupcakes on Mondays) 

SNACK CAKE – Each: $2.75 | Dozen: $33.00

Dark chocolate cake filled with our sweet decorators frosting, topped with vanilla buttercream and dipped in ganache. Our best seller.

RED VELVET – Each: $2.75 | Dozen: $33.00

Moist buttermilk cake topped with sweet cream cheese frosting.

VANILLA CREAM – Each: $2.50 | Dozen: $30.00

Our classic yellow cake topped with a vanilla buttercream rosette.

TRIPLE CHOCOLATE – Each: $2.75 | Dozen: $33.00

Our double chocolate cake topped with a dollop of chocolate frosting and a swirl of chocolate buttercream.

DAILY DESIGN – Each: $2.75 | Dozen: $33.00

Chocolate or yellow cake topped with our sweet decorators frosting in a fun design.

Daily Specialty Cupcake Menu 

Mini Monday-Chesterfield Only

All shop cupcakes in Chesterfield are mini on Mondays

MOM’S TRADITIONAL – Each: $1.75 | Dozen: $21.00

Yellow cake topped with our chocolate buttercream.

SALTED CARAMEL – Each: $1.75 | Dozen: $21.00

Caramel cake brushed with caramel sauce, topped with caramel buttercream,                                     drizzled in caramel and sprinkled in sea salt.

Tuesday

CARROT CAKE – Each: $2.75 | Dozen: $33.00

Our moist carrot cake filled with pineapple, coconut and pecans,

topped with our sweet cream cheese frosting.

CHOCOLATE COOKIEEach: $2.75 | Dozen: $33.00

Chocolate cake topped with our sweet chocolate cookie frosting.

Wednesday

LEMON SHORTBREADEach: $2.75 | Dozen: $33.00

Lemon cake baked on top of a shortbread cookie crust, iced with a lemon cream cheese frosting and sprinkled with shortbread cookie crumbs.

FLUFFERNUTTER – Each: $2.75 | Dozen: $33.00

Chocolate cake filled with marshmallow frosting, topped with whipped                                                 peanut butter buttercream and dipped in ganache.

Thursday

CLASSIC BANANAEach: $2.75 | Dozen: $33.00

Moist banana cake topped with cream cheese frosting.

EVERYDAY WEDDING CAKEEach: $2.25 | Dozen: $33.00

Almond cake topped with our traditional buttercream….here comes the bride.

TWIXEach: $2.75 | Dozen: $33.00

Caramel cake baked on a shortbread cookie crust, filled with caramel, topped with chocolate frosting dipped in ganache and drizzled with caramel and cookie crumb.

Friday

BILLIONAIRE – Each: $2.75 | Dozen: $33.00

Caramel cake filled with chocolate chip cookie dough, brushed with caramel,                                       topped with chocolate buttercream and drizzled with caramel and ganache.

FLUFFERNUTTER Each: $2.75 | Dozen: $33.00

Chocolate cake filled with marshmallow frosting, topped with whipped peanut butter              buttercream and dipped in ganache.

BOOZY BITES Each: $1.75 | 3 for $5.00

Join us for Happy Hour after 10:am on Friday’s for our fun and delicious Boozy Bites!                                                                                               MINI cupcakes created after our favorite ADULT drinks.  MUST be 21 to purchase.

Saturday

SALTED CARAMEL – Each: $2.75 | Dozen: $33.00

Caramel cake brushed with caramel sauce, topped with caramel buttercream                                            and drizzled in caramel.

LEMON SHORTBREAD – Each: $2.75 | Dozen: $33.00

Lemon cake baked on top of a shortbread cookie crust, iced with a lemon cream cheese                    frosting and sprinkled with shortbread cookie crumbs.

FIGGY GEach: $2.75 | Dozen: $33.00

White cake filled with fig jam, topped with a lightly sweetened goat cheese frosting                                  and sprinkled with toasted almonds.

Mini Sunday-Eureka Only

All shop cupcakes in Eureka are mini on Mondays

MOM’S TRADITIONAL – Each: $1.75 | Dozen: $21.00

Yellow cake topped with our chocolate buttercream.

SALTED CARAMEL – Each: $1.75 | Dozen: $21.00

Caramel cake brushed with caramel sauce, topped with                                                                             caramel buttercream and drizzled in caramel & sprinkled with sea salt.